How to beat the Jerome Gambit
Take the bishop and the knight, then give back a little material with ...Bxd4 or answer Qh5+ with ...g6 and ...Qe7. You stay a piece up with a safe king, and calm development wins.
What they are after
White sacrifices a bishop on f7 and a knight on e5 to drag your king into the open, hoping for queen checks and a fork. Objectively it is simply losing for White, but the queen checks on h5 and d5 come fast. If you know which piece to give back, you keep a full extra piece and the attack never really starts.
The answers
Against d4: ...Bxd4 and ...d6
The plan
After Nxe5+ Nxe5 d4, give back the bishop on d4. After Qxd4 play ...d6 to hold the knight on e5. You are a piece up, your king is safe enough on f7, and ...Nf6, ...Re8 and ...Kg8 finish your development.
Your chance
With your rook on e8 and king on g8, White has nothing left for the pieces.
Watch out
f4 hits your knight on e5. Keep a square ready on c6 or g6 before White plays it.
Against Qh5+: ...g6 and ...Qe7
The plan
After Qh5+, block with ...g6. When the queen takes on e5 it hits both the bishop on c5 and the rook on h8, and ...Qe7 answers both: it guards the bishop and offers a queen trade. After Qf4+ Kg7 your king is safe, and ...c6, ...h6 and ...Nf6 follow with a piece for two pawns.
Your chance
If White grabs the rook with Qxh8, ...Qxe4+ starts a mating attack against the king still on e1.
Watch out
Don’t play the natural ...d6 here: Qxh8 takes the rook and the extra piece is gone.