OpenPawn
You play Black Gambit C47

How to beat the Halloween Gambit

Take the knight with 4...Nxe5, retreat when the pawns come, and hit back with ...d5 or ...d6 to keep a piece for one or two pawns. If you prefer simple play, 5...Nc6 6.d5 Bb4 returns the piece for a lead in development.

1.e4 e5 2.♞︎f3 ♞︎c6 3.♞︎c3 ♞︎f6 4.♞︎xe5

What they are after

White sacrifices a whole knight on e5 to chase your knights with d4, e5 and sometimes f4 and d5. The pawns gain space and time, and players who don’t know the lines can get their knights trapped. Calm retreats and a well timed pawn break leave Black with more material and the better game.

The answers

Line 1

Retreat with ...Ng6 and ...Ng8, then ...d5

The plan

After d4 go back to g6, and after e5 the other knight returns to g8. It looks passive, but White has little for the piece once you strike with ...d5. After Bc4 d5 Bxd5 c6 the bishop has to retreat, and ...Be6, ...Ne7 and ...Bb4 develop with a knight for two pawns.

Your chance

Once your knights reach e7 and f5, the d4 and e5 pawns become targets and White’s compensation disappears.

Watch out

Don’t try to keep everything; if Qh5 or Qf3 with Bc4 hits f7, give a pawn back and get your king castled.

Line 2

Against 5.f4: ...Nc6, ...Ng8 and ...d6

The plan

Against f4 the knight goes back to c6, and after e5 the other one returns to g8. Then ...d6 hits the head of the chain, and White’s pawns on d4, e5 and f4 start to fall apart. You keep the extra knight for a single pawn.

Your chance

If White pushes d5, your knight goes to e7 and later ...dxe5 opens the e file towards the uncastled white king.

Watch out

Your knights on g8 and c6 need time; don’t let Qf3 or Bc4 hit f7 before you have developed and castled.

Line 3

Give back the piece with 5...Nc6 and ...Bb4

The plan

After d4 retreat to c6, and when d5 hits it, ignore the threat and pin with ...Bb4. White wins the knight back, but ...Nxe4 takes the e pawn, and after Qd4 the move ...Qe7 guards both your pieces. Material ends level, but White’s pawns are scattered and your pieces are better placed.

Your chance

The queen on e7 lines up with White’s king on e1, so moving the knight from e4 can come with a discovered check.

Watch out

Qxg7 can grab a pawn and hit your rook on h8; castle in time and keep the queen ready to defend the kingside.

Practise it