How to beat the Ponziani Opening
Answer 3.c3 with 3...Nf6 and take on e4 when White plays d4, or strike at once with 3...d5. Both moves use the fact that c3 has taken the best square from White’s knight.
What they are after
White plays c3 to build a pawn centre with d4, a plan from the 1800s that still catches people out. The price is that the queen’s knight loses its natural square and e4 is left with one defender, so Black can hit the centre before it is built.
The answers
Take the pawn with 3...Nf6 and ...Nxe4
The plan
After d4, take the e4 pawn. When d5 hits the knight on c6, go to e7 and then g6 to challenge the knight on e5. After Bd3 Nxe5 Bxe4 the material is level, and ...Bc5, ...O-O and ...d6 give you easy development against White’s advanced pawn on d5.
Your chance
With the bishop on c5 aiming at f2, ...Qh4 and ...O-O give you quick play on the kingside once White castles.
Watch out
Qa4 is White’s trick in many lines, pinning the c6 knight or hitting a loose knight on e4, so check every queen move to a4.
Counter with 3...d5
The plan
Hit e4 at once with ...d5. When Qa4 pins the knight, ...f6 keeps your e5 pawn solid and ...Ne7 prepares to recapture on d5 with a piece. After exd5 Qxd5 d4 Bd7 the pin is broken, your pieces are active and long castling is ready.
Your chance
With ...O-O-O your rook lands on the d file against d4, and the white queen on a4 is far from her own king.
Watch out
While the knight on c6 is pinned, every loose piece counts; break the pin with ...Bd7 before you open more lines.