How to beat the Marshall Attack
Don’t allow it: play 8.a4 or 8.h3 instead of 8.c3 so Black can’t push ...d5 with a gambit. If you take the pawn, know the main line with d4, Re1, g3, Be3 and Qd3.
What they are after
Black sacrifices the e5 pawn with ...d5 for a strong kingside attack against your castled king. It is so well analysed that many strong players simply avoid it, and the Anti Marshall lines are the practical answer.
The answers
Anti Marshall with 8.a4
The plan
With a4 you attack b5 before Black can play ...d5. After ...Bb7 and ...d6, play d3 and c3 and you get a slow Spanish where Black has no gambit and your pressure on the a file lasts.
Your chance
After axb5 axb5, the a file is yours and Black’s b5 pawn needs care.
Watch out
Black can play ...b4 with a normal game. Don’t expect a big edge, just a long fight.
Anti Marshall with 8.h3
The plan
With h3 you prepare d3 and c3. After ...Bb7 d3 d5, take on d5 and Black gets some play, but less than in the Marshall. Then Nc3 or Nbd2 develops.
Your chance
Black’s attack is much slower here, and your extra space tells.
Watch out
Black’s ...d5 can still be strong if you play passively. Develop quickly.
Accept the Marshall
The plan
Take the pawn with Nxe5 and Rxe5, then d4, Re1 and g3. Black attacks with ...Qh4 and ...Qh3, but with Be3, Qd3 and Nd2 you hold everything together.
Your chance
You are a pawn up if you survive, and the endgame often favours you.
Watch out
Black’s attack is very strong. Know the main lines well before you go in.