How to beat the Traxler Counterattack
Take on f7 with the bishop, not the knight, and after 5...Ke7 retreat to d5, castle and open the centre with c3 and d4. If you want no risk at all, avoid the Traxler with 4.d3.
What they are after
Black ignores the threat on f7 and plays ...Bc5, ready to answer Nxf7 with ...Bxf2+ and a wild attack on your king. The counterattack is dangerous against a greedy knight, but the calm bishop capture leaves Black a pawn down and unable to castle.
The answers
5.Bxf7+ and Bd5
The plan
Take on f7 with the bishop, with check. After ...Ke7 the bishop goes to d5, where it blocks the d pawn and hits the knight on c6. Castle, then c3 and d4 open the centre while Black’s king is still on e7. You are a pawn up and your king is the safer one.
Your chance
Black’s king on e7 blocks its own bishop and rook, and d4 opens lines towards it before it can find shelter.
Watch out
Don’t play Nxf7 instead: after ...Bxf2+ Kxf2 Nxe4+ Black gets a fierce attack that many club players lose.
Avoid it with 4.d3
The plan
With d3 instead of Ng5 you go for the quiet Italian, where Black’s Traxler ideas never appear. Develop with c3, O-O, Re1 and h3, and later reroute the queen’s knight via d2 and f1 to g3. The fight is slow and positional, and you choose the moment for d4.
Your chance
If you play the slow Italian often, you know its plans better than your opponent, and d4 at the right moment gives a lasting edge.
Watch out
The slow Italian is balanced; don’t expect a quick win, and watch the ...d5 break once your rook leaves f1.