How to beat the Schliemann Gambit
Play the solid 4.d3, which keeps e4 protected, or the main line 4.Nc3, which wins a pawn after 4...fxe4 Nxe4 Nf6. Both lines punish the weakened black king.
What they are after
Black plays ...f5 in the Ruy Lopez, a gambit in the spirit of the King’s Gambit, to hit e4 and open the f file. The move weakens the diagonal from e8 to h5 and the black king, and White’s best answers develop with tempo and aim at that weakness.
The answers
Solid 4.d3
The plan
With d3 you keep e4 protected and avoid all theory. After ...fxe4 dxe4 Nf6 O-O d6 Nc3 your pieces come out quickly, Bc4 and Ng5 hit the weak e6 and f7 squares, and Black’s king has no f pawn in front of it.
Your chance
Bc4 with Ng5 aims at e6 and f7, and a knight landing on e6 often wins the exchange.
Watch out
After ...Bg4 the pin on your knight is annoying; h3 and Qd3 break it before Black doubles on the f file.
4.Nc3 and the win of e5
The plan
After Nc3 fxe4 Nxe4 Nf6, swap on f6 and play Qe2 to hit e5. Then Bxc6 removes its defender and Nxe5 wins a pawn. Black gets the bishop pair and some activity, but you have a clean extra pawn and a safe king.
Your chance
After castling and d4 your extra centre pawn is safe, and Black’s doubled c pawns limit the bishops.
Watch out
Black’s bishops and the half open f file can make trouble; keep f2 covered and don’t rush with more pawn grabs.
4.Nc3 main line with 4...d5
The plan
Black’s main move is ...d5. Then Nxe5 hits c6, and after ...dxe4 Nxc6 Qg5 the queen move Qe2 covers g2 and e4. Next f4 drives the black queen away and the game opens around Black’s king. It is sharp but well known, and White keeps the initiative.
Your chance
After ...Qxf4 and d4, the knight on c6 can step away with a discovered check from the bishop on b5.
Watch out
One slip in the move order hands Black a raging attack; learn the line before you play 4.Nc3, or choose 4.d3.